Mexico's city planners striving to create efficient spaces for city dwellers

In 2008, for the first time in history, more than half of humanity was living in urban areas. Perhaps most remarkable about this trend is the speed at which it has happened: as recently as 1900 urban areas accounted for 13% of the population. Towns and cities are seen as the crucibles of opportunity for many rural dwellers.

The UN estimates that by 2030 urban areas will host 60% of the world’s population – up from 54.5% in 2016 – with urban growth especially rapid across Africa and parts of Asia. Urban areas are home to more than 470m people in Africa, accounting for 40% of the continent’s population, up from 14% in the mid-1900s.

Growing Pains

In 2016 there were 512 cities with at least 1m inhabitants, more than 100 of which were in China. By 2030 this number is set to increase to 660, with around 40 categorised as mega-cities home to more than 10m inhabitants, including Bogotá, Bangkok, Dar es Salaam and Ho Chi Minh City.

All cities, even those in prosperous and stable countries, face challenges, from providing adequate housing, sanitation, transport and energy, to combatting pollution and inequality. Not surprisingly, these issues are magnified in developing and emerging countries, where limited resources and weak institutions can struggle to cope with eventualities such as waves of migrants or the effects of climate change. Nonetheless, opportunities abound for municipal authorities to create urban areas that are sustainable, dynamic, healthy and safe.

Building Innovations

The construction sector is not generally considered a front runner in embracing innovation. The basic techniques using brick and timber date back centuries and – often for sound economic or aesthetic reasons – they have tended not to evolve dramatically. However, this tendency is changing, spearheaded by the advent of lighter, stronger and more flexible materials, along with innovative techniques such as modular construction and 3D printing.

While large projects are increasingly complex, industry players can use tools like building information modelling (BIM), robotics and the internet of things to facilitate this. These can improve efficiency and lower costs, while also enhancing quality and sustainability, which will be important, as many urban areas need to be resilient against earthquakes and extreme weather, such as tropical storms, flash floods and heatwaves.

Technology & Project Management

The process by which buildings are constructed and woven into wider infrastructure is of the utmost importance, with projects becoming increasingly complex and challenging to deliver. The IHS Herold Global Projects Database estimates that productivity has declined since the early 2000s; large infrastructure projects, for example, cost on average 80% more than the original budget and run more than 20 months late. Many are also delivered with defects, suggesting project management teams have failed to cope with rising complexity and external risks.

Technology can play a role in developing more streamlined construction and infrastructure schemes, and in recent years BIM has been at the forefront. It combines 3D-modelling software with layers of data on every detail along a project’s timeline, providing architects and engineers with a relatively simple way of rigorously testing and analysing designs. BIM has been widely adopted across Europe, the US, South Korea, Singapore and the Gulf. In the UK the government requires all centrally procured contracts to achieve BIM Level 2.

Take-up has unsurprisingly been slower in emerging markets, but in 2017 Dubai became the first public authority to mandate the use of BIM for most of its large-scale building projects. The neighbouring emirate of Abu Dhabi also uses BIM, which has notably been employed on the $3bn Midfield Terminal Building by Abu Dhabi Airports Company.

Smart Cities

The miniaturisation of sensors and the evolution of the internet means that information on almost all aspects of urban life – from air and water quality, to the movement of people and objects, weather, road and rail traffic, and energy generation and consumption – can be measured in real time. By linking houses, public buildings, factories, vehicles, power stations, traffic signals and street lighting, cities can be smart and responsive to the needs of residents. Developments in smart metering, solar photovoltaic technology and battery storage are leading to more local energy generation, which should facilitate the shift to cleaner, more efficient and quieter electric vehicles.

Qatar has embraced the smart city concept as it prepares to host the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Lusail. On the outskirts of Doha, the city is being developed with smart technology, incorporating sustainability to enhance residents’ quality of life. “Lusail City was the first in Qatar to endorse the Global Sustainability Assessment System principles, and to rate all buildings according to their sustainability and performance,” Nabeel Mohammed Al Buenain, group CEO of real estate developer Qatari Diar, told OBG.

The city will offer residents and visitors smart transport and communications services, overseen by a central management facility. Meanwhile, in the renovated Msheireb area of Doha, several services offer a smart experience. “These include navigation, people counting, help desks, online payments, CCTV, fire alarms and infrastructure network applications,” Ahmad Mohamed Al Kuwari, CEO of IT firm MEEZA, told OBG.

In the face of a rapidly urbanising population, smart cities are also being developed in numerous African nations, including Kenya’s Konza Technological City, 60 km outside of Nairobi and extending over 2020 ha of land. Dubbed “Silicon Savannah”, the project is part of Vision 2030, the country’s national development strategy, and is slated to see a combined $15.5bn in investment. Due for completion after 2030, the project is set to create 100,000 jobs and generate $1bn annually, according to the Konza Development Authority.

Another example is the Eko Atlantic project in Nigeria, bordering Lagos’s Bar Beach coastline and spanning 10 sq km. Though the economic climate has slowed work, the project is expected to attract 150,000 daily commuters and host various amenities upon completion, including high-end housing for up to 250,000 residents.

The New Administrative Capital, Egypt’s new capital unveiled in 2016, is also working to integrate smart networks. Slated for delivery by 2022, the city is 50 km from Cairo and will extend over 700 sq km. It aims to alleviate congestion, provide homes to 5m people and host some main public institutions. In late 2017 another smart city was announced in Aswan, near Egypt’s Western Desert, to accommodate the city’s growing population. The development will cover 1620 ha, including housing, recreational facilities and green areas.

Challenged Urbanisation

Smart cities are now firmly on the radar across the world, but older metropolises are also embracing digital technology to improve service delivery and quality of life. Buenos Aires, for example, has recently surveyed its infrastructure and developed an application – the SAP HANA platform – to speed up administrative processes. The city of 16m inhabitants has 372,625 trees, 91,000 street lights, 50,700 pavements, 30,000 storm drains and 27,000 roads. Previously, certifying maintenance and repair work was very time-consuming and tedious, requiring thousands of sheets of paper to be printed and filed.

For other cities in emerging markets, using big data for urban planning and smart infrastructure may seem far removed from the reality of urban sprawl, traffic congestion, air pollution, flooding and sanitation problems. Yangon, Myanmar’s largest city, illustrates this. Following six decades of military rule and international isolation, the city lacks an effective public transport system and suffers from chronic congestion. “During the last decades the expansion of the city was not followed by the modernisation of its infrastructure, and this is now putting pressure on both city management and public services,” U Phyo Min Thein, chief minister of the Regional Government of Yangon, told OBG.

Misaligned Driver

Housing construction has been a key growth driver in Yangon since reforms began in 2011, but developers have focused on the upper-tier segments, due to the paucity of accommodation and Myanmar’s position as a frontier market in a dynamic region. In 2013 rents in central areas soared above those in Bangkok and even parts of Manhattan. However, this resulted in an oversupply of high-end units and not enough affordable housing for average families.

Similarly, rapid urbanisation and the adoption of smart networks has been challenging across Africa. At 4.5%, the continent has the world’s highest urban growth rate; by 2050 more than half of the population is set to be living in cities, an important demographic shift.

While there has been progress in developing some urban centres, infrastructure works often lag behind, on the back of slow structural transformation, a historical dependence on natural resources and weak levels of industrialisation. Inadequate urban planning and underinvestment in infrastructure have seen informal settlements proliferate, as is the case in Lagos, Africa’s most-populous city. With over 21m people and growing at 3.2% per year, Lagos has experienced unprecedented urbanisation, leading to the development of slums. However, as the government aims to turn the city into the “Dubai of Africa”, settlements are being cleared, as was the case for Ilubirin and Otodo-Gbame, bordering the waterfront, in 2016. Despite challenges of population growth and the lack of accommodating infrastructure, the city acts as an economic engine, accounting for over 35% of GDP and 62.3% of non-oil GDP in 2010, per the UN Economic Commission for Africa.

Growth Potential

This is a testament to the potential cities have as drivers of transformation and economic growth. In addition to developing infrastructure, promoting economic efficiency, improving urban density and ensuring social inclusion, the success of Africa’s urban centres will depend on their ability to create employment for the continent’s ever-growing youth population. With more than half of Africans under the age of 18.5, and 19% between 15 and 24 years old, this represents a both significant challenge and a potential opportunity should it be tapped effectively.

The African Development Bank, the OECD and the UN Development Programme produced a report in 2016 calling for policy reforms to optimise the “urbanisation dividend”, and for African countries to spend 5-7% of GDP per year on infrastructure. According to the report, two-thirds of the investment needed in urban infrastructure through 2050 has yet to be made, highlighting key opportunities. The future of Africa hinges on the efficient management and development of cities, turning major centres into sustainable growth engines.

Master Plans

Sustainable cities require more than dynamic construction. Myanmar’s municipal authorities are developing a master plan based on other regional cities, but a lack of skills, weak institutions, legal uncertainty and limited financing could constrain progress.

Plans are also afoot for the Yangon New City Project, a 12,140-ha development to alleviate congestion and reduce informal settlements. The project is supported by multilateral organisations and is set to make extensive use of public-private partnerships. However, sustained work is required to strengthen the tax system, as well as replicate international best practices in harnessing private finance to improve public services.

Curbing Sprawl

In devising plans for the sustainable development of Yangon, Abidjan, São Paulo, or smart cities on the outskirts of Cairo and Jeddah, sprawl poses a significant challenge. Architects and urban planners recognise a key distinction between expansion and sprawl: cities have expanded throughout history and will continue to do so, but sprawl is a relatively recent and undesirable phenomenon. It includes not only low-density suburbs, but also sterile apartment blocks, which have sprouted up in large numbers.

In her seminal text, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, writer and activist Jane Jacobs argued that the dramatic growth of car traffic separates city dwellers from each other and the natural environment. This, she claims, precludes the cross-fertilisation and interactions that allow humanity to thrive. In addition to facilitating sprawl, private cars bring traffic congestion, causing losses in productivity and increases in stress, mental illness and non-communicable diseases from inactivity, and other health conditions from air pollution.

Jan Gehl, an urban architect, wrote about the importance of providing safe places to walk or cycle and enjoy outdoor spaces. Others refer to the “Goldilocks density”, at which buildings are densely populated enough to provide retail and services to vibrant main streets, but not so tall that people are removed from the streetscape. Buildings of six or seven storeys allow the sun to penetrate to street level, making it easier for ground-floor cafes to spill out onto the street, creating a sense of community and vibrant street life. Such buildings can also accommodate a large number of people: traditional Parisian districts house up to 26,000 people per sq km, while Barcelona’s Eixample district reaches 36,000 inhabitants in the same surface area.

Urban Principles

While working to manage their expanding populations, city authorities are likely to work to preserve natural ecologies, historical sites and architecture to imbue urban communities with a sense of identity. The benefits of mixed-use infrastructure as well as mixed-income communities to prevent monolithic neighbourhoods divided by wealth is also likely to shape urban planning in cities across the world.

In terms of urban transport, investment in high-quality and affordable mass transit systems, and a focus on matching city density with transport capacity, is key to keeping cities moving. The increasing take-up of smart infrastructure is likely to make this job easier. The convergence of streets to allow for multiple modes of transport on a single path may likewise become popular if it enhances the potential for mass transit systems to gain traction in previously car-dominated areas. At the same time, an emphasis on walkability and bicycle access to reduce road congestion is being seen as important for both the health of the environment and urban dwellers, as well as a sense of community.

The model of urban planning that extended from modernism and its vision of the city as a machine have proven popular over the past half century – and it endures. But there is a growing realisation that if urban areas are to be lively, safe, healthy and sustainable, they will need to develop a different form and complexion.